money pipe
– Getty Images

Network operators have spent untold trillions of dollars building out expansive connectivity platforms that have come to underpin the world’s current economy, yet those same operators have failed repeatedly to reap an equal reward for the value that investment has provided, failures that makes it hard to believe that history won’t repeat.

Sure, those network operators collect trillions of dollars each year in network-related revenues, but the margin on that stream falls significantly below that of the companies providing services that run atop those networks. And that’s something those operators are constantly aware of and reminded about.

This is known as the “dumb pipe” syndrome that has seen those gold-plated networks treated as basic plumbing, best left unseen and unloved by the digital economy that runs through those pipes, or at least until it doesn’t. And it drives telecom operators crazy.

Meyer BW
Is there money in those pipes? – Dan Meyer

I can’t tell you how many times I have seen and heard operators attempt to compete with or compare themselves to application developers, cloud providers, and any other industry that has reaped significant financial benefit on the back of network operator toil.

And it’s with such reverence that network operators are again attempting to insert themselves into the latest financial windfall: AI.

Network operators have so far tapped the AI ecosystem in an attempt to drive operating efficiencies, mimicking what just about every other business entity has been trying to do over the past couple of years. And it has provided some benefit, though I am sure there are a few tens-of-thousands of former telecom employees that might say otherwise.

But, those operators are now turning their AI-related gaze to an even sexier AI target: they want to be “token brokers.”

For those not in the know, tokens are the financial currency used to monetize AI-aligned transactions. Want to send some amount of data off to be AI-ified? That will cost you some tokens. How many tokens? Well, that depends.

More pertinent to this diatribe is that network operators think they can use their physical presence – their gold-plated network – in the sending and receiving of that data to extract a piece of that nebulous token amount.

Kenechi Okeleke, director for regional, social, and policy research at GSMA, explained in a recent blog post that operators do indeed have an inside track based on long-standing “trusted” customer relationships around “billing and identity capabilities; local support; security and compliance expertise; connectivity; regulatory knowledge; and sovereign or distributed infrastructure.”

That opportunity was obvious at the recent Brooklyn AI-Native 6G Summit, which itself highlighted the importance of this attempted shift by adding the “AI-Native” part ahead of its previously headlining “6G” label.

Network operators at the event expressed their interest in being a token broker.

It’s good to have a plan

But what exactly would that position look like?

Well, Verizon CTO Yago Tenorio explained to the event audience an example of an AI agent embedded in a single-purpose device.

“That's going to be measured in tokens, the relationship with the customer is going to be in tokens, so our metering needs to be in tokens, and we need to ride that wave,” Tenorio said. “Now, we can broker the tokens, we can produce the tokens, we can connect the tokens. I think we should do all three.”

Takki Yu, SVP for SK Telecom, also backed that opportunity, noting there “will be huge opportunity for a telco operator in their business” in being a “token gateway or broker.”

Yu explained that operators have their “own assets, including [a] nationwide network, and also a lot of experience for authentication and security systems” for the telecom market, “and all of these can be used in” the token space. However, Yu did add that the key would be to find a way to work with the ecosystem on a revenue sharing model.

And that’s the rub.

You see, while many of us were taught to share back in preschool, modern business principles frown on such appeasement. This as left the telecom market out of the broader ecosystem discussion of revenue sharing. They want to be part of that conversation. They have repeatedly stated that they need to be part of that conversation. And yet, they have mostly been shut out of that conversation.

Some have started to make their case that they deserve a seat at this revenue table.

AT&T CFO Pascal Desroches proclaimed earlier this year that “AI doesn't exist without our connectivity … plain and simple,” a notion that operators have started to somewhat monetize, but in more traditional ways.

Verizon CEO Dan Schulman, for example, recently touted the carrier was sitting on $4 billion worth of contracts tied to carrying AI-related data from hyperscalers across its network.

But a plan can only take you so far

But that doesn’t get them to being a token broker, which is where the real money can be made.

And while they can make the case that they should get a cut of that loot, telecom operators have a history of fumbling such real opportunity.

“The opportunity is real, but the window to act is narrowing,” Okeleke warned. “The AI economy is moving faster than the telecom industry is used to, and hyperscalers, cloud providers, and AI-native companies are already building the platforms and control layers that will shape access to AI services. Telcos bring powerful advantages, including trusted customer relationships, local presence, regulatory expertise, connectivity, and distributed infrastructure, but they cannot assume those strengths will remain uncontested.”

I would like to believe network operators will this time take a real stand and take their rightful piece of this financial opportunity, and it’s good to hear them at least talking about how they can capitalize on their unique position in the ecosystem.

But, I have also been burned more times than I would like to remember on past hopes of such success, a mental trauma that makes it hard to believe this time will be different.